This thesis was intended for researcher Zain al-Abidin Salem Mardan with description, analysis and criticism, which are procedures and studies (criticism of criticism) which is contained in the message and is based on detection, comparison and analysis in the study of research studies of the Journal of Foreign Culture issued by the House of Public Cultural Affairs in Baghdad, and giving a special critical view of each study, which he sees  It deserves to stand, it has adopted the method of presenting the critical text or the critical study, and standing when we find it necessary to discuss, analyze or criticize it.  Some models that can fulfill the purpose we want to reach